NRA CrimeStrike's CrimeWatch Weekly Breaking news on critical crime-fighting issues, policies and legislation Vol. 2, No. 12 August 13, 1996 First-Ever Study On Right-To-Carry Laws And Crime Released At a forum at the Washington, D.C.-based libertarian Cato Institute on Aug. 8, Dr. John Lott, Jr., of the University of Chicago Law School, released the findings of the first comprehensive study of the effects of right-to-carry laws on crime rates. In the study's introduction, Dr. Lott synthesized the controversy over allowing lawabiding citizens to exercise their right to lawful self-defense outside the home by lawfully carrying firearms: "Will allowing concealed handguns make it likely that otherwise law-abiding citizens will harm each other, or will the threat of citizens carrying weapons primarily deter criminals?" While in previous Dept. of Justice research 74% of criminals interviewed agreed they would avoid burglarizing occupied homes for fear of being shot by an armed homeowner, Dr. Lott's study is the first to take research one step further by evaluating nationally the effect of right-to-carry laws on crime. The University of Chicago study findings: When state right-to-carry laws went into effect in a county, murders fell 8.5%, rapes fell by 5%, and aggravated assaults fell by 7%. According to NRA CrimeStrike Director Elizabeth Swasey, "We must never forget that these percentages represent living, breathing people our friends and families. Dr. Lott found that if states that did not have right-to-carry laws had adopted them in 1992, that every year approximately 1,570 fewer people would have been murdered, 4,177 fewer women and children raped, and 60,000 fewer people victimized by aggravated assaults." In the past nine years, NRA has helped 23 states pass or reform discriminatory right-to-carry laws. The University of Chicago Law School professor's report, "Crime, Deterrence and Right-to-Carry Concealed Handguns," co-authored with graduate student David Mustard, is scheduled for publication in The Journal of Legal Studies this January, However, it is available online now at http://WWW.lib.uchicago.edu/~llou/guns.html. Washington High Court Upholds '3 Strikes' The constitutionality of Washington state's "Three Strikes and You're Out" law, the first in the nation when it was approved by 77% of the state's voters in 1993, has been upheld by the State Supreme Court. The rulings handed down last Thursday came on the appeals of three "lifers" who said, among other things, that the state law violated the constitutional separation of powers by giving prosecutors more descretion than judges during sentencing, that the law gave "decisive power" to prosecutors in plea bargaining, and that the law amounted to cruel and unusual punishment. In contrast to the outcome in Washington, last month California's high court gutted that state's "Three Strikes" law by ruling that judges can ignore the prior "strike" convictions that render defendants eligible for enhancement of their prison sentences after a third strike. NRA CrimeStrike played a major role in passage of the Washington law and has helped "three strikes" become a national movement, now the law in more than 20 states across the nation. Stay tuned. Penn. Sen. Fisher Earns CrimeStrike 'Justice' Award Pennsylvania State Senator Mike Fisher is the fifth state official nationally to receive NRA CrimeStrike's "Defender of Justice" award recognizing outstanding achievement in enacting tough criminal justice reform that saves lives. The award was presented last Thursday in Harrisburg by Tanya K. Metaksa, Executive Director of the NRA Institute for Legislative Action. "With this award, we recognize the leadership of Sen. Fisher in achieving a truly remarkable accomplishment top to bottom reconstruction of a Pennsylvania criminal justice system that was in desperate need of reform," Mrs. Metaksa told those attending. Senator Fisher, who wrote the state's law mandating a five-year prison sentence for using a gun in a crime, served as Senate leader in charge of the legislature's 1995 special session on crime that passed 37 new laws, including the death penalty for aggravated murder. Additionally, Senator Fisher authored the state's law "waiving" juveniles charged with violent crimes to adult court and led the fight for Pennsylvania's "Three Strikes and You're Out" law, Metaksa noted. "Mike understands what makes families safe punishment that is certain and swift for criminally attacking another person," Mrs. Metaksa said. QUESTIONS? GET ANSWERS. LEGISLATIVE: 800.868.4411 PRESS: 703.267.3820 INTERNET: HTTP://WWW.NRA.ORG A publication of NRA CrimeStrike 11250 Waples Mill Rd., Fairfax, VA 22030 Tel.800.868.4411; Fax 703.267.3992; HTTP://www.nra.org. Reproduction permitted with credit. Source materials available. =+=+=+=+ This information is provided as a service of the National Rifle Association Institute for Legislative Action, Fairfax, VA. This and other information on the Second Amendment and the NRA is available at: http://WWW.NRA.Org